$1,000 deduction guidance welcome, but costly policy remains poorly targeted
The Institute of Public Accountants (IPA) has welcomed the Australian Taxation Office (ATO)’s draft ruling on the $1,000 standard deduction for work-related expenses, but reiterated that the measure is a costly, poorly targeted form of cost-of-living relief.
The IPA does not support the policy as implemented because the deduction is available to every taxpayer earning salary or wages, rather than being directed to those most in need.
A factory worker on the minimum wage with legitimate deductions is treated the same as a high-income salaried employee with no work deductions, yet receives a disproportionately greater tax benefit under the standard deduction regime. Sole traders also miss out on the standard deduction, even though they make up the majority of small businesses in Australia.
However, it is acknowledged that the measure could simplify compliance for millions of taxpayers as it is an automatic entitlement if you earn salary or wages and requires ‘no substantiation’ of your deductions.
Tony Greco, Senior Tax Advisor at the IPA, said the draft guidance was broadly welcome, subject to several technical refinements, but it did not address the policy’s fundamental shortcomings.
“The guidance is a useful step and should make the new deduction easier to administer, but it does not change our view that this is an expensive and poorly targeted policy response to cost-of-living pressures,” Mr Greco said.
“Taxpayers with work-related deductions of $1,000 or less may benefit from simpler record-keeping. Those with legitimate deductions above $1,000 receive little practical relief and are more likely to face greater scrutiny when substantiating their claims,” Mr Greco said. “The removal of commonly used substantiation exceptions exacerbates the compliance burden for those taxpayers.”
The IPA has called for the final ruling to explain whether new tax return stationery will include a dedicated standard deduction field, whether taxpayers must make an explicit election to use the deduction, and how other deductible work-related expenses which fall outside the ambit of the standard deduction should be reported.
“These mechanics matter. The ATO, myTax and commercial software must apply the rules consistently, and taxpayers should not lose legitimate deductions because the process is unclear,” Mr Greco said.
The IPA also recommended practical examples covering part-year residents and assets used to earn both employment and business income, such as computers, desks and air conditioners.
“The standard deduction does not remove the broader complexity of work-related expense rules. As a greater number of taxpayers work from home, more individuals will find themselves exceeding the deduction limit, once they calculate their legitimate work-from-home expenses.” Mr Greco said.
“The final ruling should resolve the remaining technical issues and give taxpayers and practitioners a workable lodgment process. That would improve administration, but it should not be mistaken for fixing the policy’s high cost, broad reach or limited benefit for people with deductions above $1,000,” Mr Greco said.
Media contact: Yulia Fokina | 0419 540 936 | yulia.fokina@publicaccountants.org.au
About the Institute of Public Accountants
The IPA is a professional accounting body representing more than 50,000 members and students in 100 countries. It advocates for members, the accounting profession and for a tax and regulatory environment that supports small business, practitioners and the broader economy.
