New draft, same problems: Trusts tax bill still misses the mark
The Institute of Public Accountants (IPA) has expressed disappointment that the Government's minimum tax on discretionary trusts legislation, introduced into Parliament last week, fails to address the most significant concerns raised by the accounting profession and the small business community during consultation.
The legislation contains several refinements compared to the exposure draft but leaves fundamental policy and practical issues unresolved. “The Government has not addressed the issues that matter most for family businesses and professional advisers,” said Tony Greco, Senior Tax Advisor.
“Businesses are still facing three deeply unpalatable choices: accept the punitive minimum tax, undertake an expensive and disruptive restructure, or elect to permanently restrict the flexibility that has made trust structures work well for flourishing and ever-changing businesses.”
The treatment of corporate beneficiaries, which will result in exorbitant double taxation, remains a key concern for viable businesses operating out of a trust structure. The IPA warns that this outcome has the potential to significantly increase the costs for many longstanding business groups that use entirely legitimate structures.
“The reality is that these arrangements are not exotic tax structures. They are commonly used by family businesses across Australia for financing, asset protection and commercial reasons,” Mr Greco said.
The IPA is also concerned that the new, limited Commissioner of Taxation’s discretion in relation to the automatic revocation of trust elections does little to solve the inflexibility problem underlying the election regime.
“The election regime has been built on the assumption that distribution arrangements can be predetermined indefinitely. That assumption bears little resemblance to how families and businesses operate over the course of years and decades,” Mr Greco said.
“Families and stakeholders change. Businesses evolve. The baton is passed to the next generation. The rules continue to underestimate the importance of flexibility in responding to those realities.”
The consequences for succession planning are particularly troubling. The embedded restrictions may make that process substantially more difficult and less efficient than it is today.
The IPA is disappointed that there is still no meaningful relief from the substantial costs and administrative burdens for businesses that decide restructuring is their only viable option. Even with the transitional income tax relief, business owners will still face significant legal, accounting, valuation and implementation costs - all at a time of cost-of-living pressures, economic uncertainty and broader regulatory change.
Compounding these concerns is ongoing uncertainty regarding the interaction of the new regime with state trust laws and state-based stamp duty provisions.
The New South Wales Government's recent announcement of stamp duty relief is welcome. However, the IPA warns that it will only be available to trusts that choose the election route and will not extend to entity restructures and asset transfers.
“Businesses are being asked to make decisions with permanent and costly consequences at a time when a number of critical questions remain unanswered,” Mr Greco said. The Australian Small Business and Family Enterprise Ombudsman (ASBFEO) has independently highlighted the array of additional costs and disruption that changes to discretionary trust will potentially have on small businesses.
“The IPA continues to support genuine tax reform. However, reform should not come at the expense of flexibility, succession planning and the viability of legitimate business structures.”
“The consultation process identified serious structural defects in the proposal. The legislation before Parliament leaves most of those defects intact. We urge Parliament to address these unresolved issues before the legislation progresses further.”
Media contact: Yulia Fokina | 0419 540 936 | yulia.fokina@publicaccountants.org.au
About the Institute of Public Accountants
The IPA is a professional accounting body representing more than 50,000 members and students in 100 countries. It advocates for members, the accounting profession and for a tax and regulatory environment that supports small business, practitioners and the broader economy.
