The least worst option: Treasury trust reform no easy fix for small business
The Institute of Public Accountants (IPA) has warned that the Treasury’s latest proposed option for discretionary trusts may reduce the need for some costly restructures, but it is far from a simple solution for small businesses and their advisers.
The exposure draft legislation for the proposed 30 per cent minimum tax on discretionary trusts, due to apply from 1 July 2028, includes a new Excluded Election Trust option that would allow eligible trusts to avoid the minimum tax by committing to fixed distributions to pre-nominated beneficiaries.
IPA Senior Tax Advisor Tony Greco said the new option appears to respond to widespread concerns raised during earlier consultation, but the practical consequences should not be underestimated.
“While the Excluded Election Trust option may help some taxpayers avoid the disruption of a forced restructure, or the harsh impact of a 30 per cent minimum tax where corporate beneficiaries are involved, it is no walk in the park,” Mr Greco said.
“The proposal effectively hard codes nominated beneficiaries and fixed distribution percentages, with extremely limited opportunity for variation. That creates significant practical difficulties for trustees and advisers who may need flexibility as family, business or legal circumstances change.”
Mr Greco said a single misstep could carry serious consequences, with an inconsistent distribution potentially revoking the election permanently and exposing the trustee to tax on all trust income at the top marginal rate plus Medicare in that year, while the minimum 30 per cent rate would apply in future years.
“This is not simply a tax administration issue. Trust deeds are legal documents governed by state law, and trustees have fiduciary obligations to act in the best interests of beneficiaries,” Mr Greco said.
“Tax practitioners cannot provide legal advice on trust deeds, yet they may be asked to help clients opt into a regime that could be inconsistent with the deed or with trustees’ broader legal obligations. That creates real risk for practitioners and clients alike.”
The IPA said discretionary trust deeds may share common features, but each deed is unique to the entity and its circumstances. Adding another layer of eligibility rules and ongoing compliance obligations risks increasing costs for small business owners already facing significant pressure.
“At a time when businesses are under pressure, and the economy needs stronger productivity, this is another complex compliance burden that will divert time and resources away from running a business,” Mr Greco said.
“Businesses will need to make difficult decisions about the future use of discretionary trust structures well before the proposed 1 July 2028 start date. The uncertainty about where these reforms will ultimately land is unwelcome and needs to be resolved with practical guidance.”
The IPA has urged the Treasury to ensure the final rules recognise the legal complexity of trust arrangements and do not leave small businesses and advisers exposed to unnecessary cost, uncertainty and risk.
Media contact: Yulia Fokina | 0419 540 936 | yulia.fokina@publicaccountants.org.au
About the Institute of Public Accountants
The IPA is a professional accounting body representing more than 50,000 members and students in 100 countries. It advocates for members, the accounting profession and for a tax and regulatory environment that supports small business, practitioners and the broader economy.
