When tax debt becomes a crisis, the right support can change the outcome

For Australian businesses struggling with tax debt, securing a sustainable and compliant payment arrangement and achieving GIC remission success with the ATO is becoming an increasingly difficult proposition. And for the accountants advising them, the consequences of an unsuccessful negotiation can extend well beyond the immediate financial pressure.
Andrew Zell, Head of Growth and Partnerships at Tax Debt Manager (TDM), says the ATO has become more assertive in its debt recovery activity, with a more stringent approach to negotiations and a greater willingness to pursue outstanding liabilities.
“I doubt I’m delivering any eye watering news by saying debt collection activity has really ramped up over the past 12 months. It’s got quicker, it’s more severe and it’s having a huge effect not only on the financial aspect for business owners but a massive impact socially,” he says.
While the ATO has a responsibility to recover unpaid taxes, Zell believes the pace and intensity of its collection activity can leave businesses with limited ability and time to address underlying cash-flow difficulties.
The problem is compounded by the circumstances in which tax debt often arises. An unexpected disruption to trading, rising operating expenses, unpaid contracts, increases in fuel and costs of goods or labour, or personal difficulties affecting an owner can quickly undermine a business’s ability to meet its obligations.
For accountants, the challenge is not simply to help clients negotiate payment terms, but to determine whether those arrangements are sustainable and whether other options should be explored before financial difficulties escalate. TDM often deals with matters where the accountant deems it to be a lost cause however a workable solution can be achieved.
“We definitely respect the ATO and the job they need to do, our job is to work on behalf of our client but in conjunction with the ATO to achieve mutually beneficial outcomes,” Zell says.
“We have a good working relationship and there’s nothing better than achieving a great outcome for our clients while the ATO still collects revenue they’re owed.
“Whilst things can often seem cut and dried, it’s always worth exploring what’s possible. I have many clients get on our first call stressed out of their minds and by the time we’ve finished they can see a light at the end of the tunnel and it’s common to hear that this one conversation has lifted a weight off their shoulders.”
When a temporary setback becomes a serious problem
Tax debt difficulties are not always the result of a fundamentally unviable business.
Zell says financial pressures often begin with a disruption to cash flow, whether caused by economic conditions, rising input costs or an unexpected event affecting the owner.
“Something affects the cash flow, they begin to get behind, and the problem starts snowballing from there,” he says.
“For many, it can be very hard to play catch-up and we know all too well the pressures this puts on clients, of course there are some businesses which can handle it and recover quickly and easily, but the large majority need help,”
He believes many owners are reluctant to acknowledge how serious the problem has become, particularly when they feel responsible for the livelihoods of their employees.
“Business owners really take deep responsibility of their staff, their families and the living they’re providing for their employees, this is sometimes to the detriment of their own business and financial state,” Zell says.
For accountants, that makes early conversations particularly important. A client relying on future income to meet existing tax liabilities, repeatedly missing payments or struggling to maintain cash reserves may need assistance before formal recovery action begins.
The difficulty, Zell says, is that business owners often assume they can recover their position once trading improves. By the time they recognise that the debt has become unmanageable, their options may have narrowed. Once it reaches this stage, it is often confusing and overwhelming what option to take to tackle the problem. Often this is where hastened decisions are made to immediately look to SBR and insolvency type action as the only remedy.
A changing environment for ATO negotiations
Zell says the ATO’s debt recovery approach has shifted considerably over the past year, with businesses and their advisers encountering greater scrutiny and less flexibility when seeking payment arrangements and remission of interest and penalties.
“The ability for accountants and clients to go and obtain a workable payment arrangement and remissions has been much tougher to come by,” he says.
Zell recognises the ATO’s responsibility to recover outstanding revenue and maintain a fair system for businesses that meet their tax obligations. However, he says the increasingly stringent approach to debt collection has changed the way accountants need to prepare for negotiations. The approach and strategies of say 2 to 3 years ago have changed drastically.
Strategies and processes that may previously have secured an acceptable payment arrangement are no longer necessarily producing the same results. This places greater strain on the accountant's time, and a greater importance on understanding a client’s financial position and the terms they can realistically sustain.
“Often we see payment arrangements set up that, yes, tick the box and they’ve got a payment arrangement, but it’s not going to be sustainable long term but it’s the best that the accountant or client could achieve at the time under pressure,” he says.
A business may then default several months later, leaving it exposed to further recovery action and potentially complicating future negotiations.
“The only way to keep yourself protected is to be in a formal payment arrangement and stay compliant, voluntary payments are great but it will no longer act as a deterrent to future action,” he says.
A business given time to recover
A recent case involving a Western Australian trade-based business illustrates how those considerations can affect the outcome.
The business owner had suffered an injury, several employees had left and operations had become increasingly difficult to manage. Although future work was lined up, cash flow had deteriorated and the business had accumulated approximately $400,000 in tax debt.
Its accountant had made several attempts to negotiate a payment arrangement with the ATO, supported by cash-flow projections and other documentation, but was unable to secure anything satisfactory, leaving the business completely exposed.
The payment period offered, however, was 18 months.
“That was just no way doable considering the pressures they were under,” Zell says.
The accountant referred the matter to TDM, whose team reviewed the business’ circumstances and negotiated a 36-month arrangement, with substantially reduced payments during the first year.
The revised terms provided time for the owner to return to work, complete outstanding contracts and arrange some additional finance to put part way to the debt.
“We got them to a point where we were able to secure 36 months, with the first 12 months at a much-reduced rate,” Zell says.
“That meant, most importantly, they were able to protect themselves first and foremost, and stay compliant long term.”
The arrangement did not eliminate the debt, but it gave the business an opportunity to stabilise its operations while continuing to meet its commitments.
After several months, the business had begun reducing its debt and the owner had returned to work.
“The owner is back on the tools and the business is firing well enough to make headway into the debt. The owner has gone from facing ATO enforcement action which was very close to ending the business, to buying enough time to recover, release some funding from equity to pay down the debt to an even more manageable level, and continue to trade out of their issue which was their intent the whole time.
“They weren’t looking to hide from their obligations, they just needed help. The time and structure simply wasn’t there before and funders weren’t willing to act without the debt being in a payment arrangement. At the right time and with continued good compliance, we will make a strategic application for remissions of interest and penalties which we’ve had good success both in the past and in recent times despite being a much tougher environment to achieve these remissions. Full credit goes to our team on this front,” Zell says.
For the accountant, who had already made considerable efforts to assist the client, the outcome demonstrated what specialist negotiation experience could contribute and the client was over the moon.
Zell says the case also illustrates the broader consequences of a business nearly being forced to close when a workable alternative may still exist.
The business continued trading, its employees retained their jobs and the owner has gained time to rebuild. This demonstrates how tailoring the correct structure can also benefit the societal aspects of ATO debt and how it has a flow on effect to families and the community in general.
Knowing when to seek specialist support
Zell is careful to distinguish between businesses that can realistically recover and those for which formal restructuring or insolvency may be necessary.
“We’re certainly not anti-insolvency. We’re only anti-insolvency when it doesn’t need to happen,” he says.
His concern is that accountants and business owners may pursue those options inadvertently and with no ill intent meant, due to simply not knowing another possible solution exists. A large majority of ATO debt can be nuanced to suit the client and ATO therefore providing a positive outcome for all parties. If for some reason, things aren’t sustainable long term then insolvency/bankruptcy can become the fall back option but at least all options were explored, if that is what the client wants in the first place.
Small business restructure (SBR’s), liquidation and bankruptcy all have their place, but each can carry significant consequences for an owner’s financial position and future commercial activities.
For instance, there is a lot of social media and advertising regarding the benefits of SBR’s however there has been a significant decrease in the number of SBR’s being approved and the cents in the dollar figure has increased significantly from when they were first introduced. SBR’s still definitely have their place but TDM is seeing many clients being referred to them after a failed SBR. The issue in those cases is the client has paid considerable fees to do the SBR and now have a failed SBR on their file and the debt still exists. Not only this, but it will also affect future ATO negotiations let alone any potential finance options.
Zell believes specialist assistance is worth considering when negotiations have stalled, the time constraints on the accountant have become overbearing, proposed payment terms aren’t ideal or an accountant feels at a loss as to where to turn next.
“The thing that kills us the most is finding out about people we could have helped but it’s now too late,” he says.
Line in the sand between TDM and the Accountant or Adviser
TDM works specifically on ATO debt matters, supporting accountants rather than replacing their broader advisory relationships with clients. TDM isn’t an accountancy firm and sticks purely to assisting advisers and their clients to negotiate ATO debt. The firm describes its approach through the ethos “Ethical Experts Curing ATO Pain”, reflecting its emphasis on specialist knowledge, practical solutions and an empathetic approach to helping business owners navigate difficult circumstances.
Zell says the firm offers an initial assessment without cost or obligation, allowing accountants and business owners to understand whether specialist assistance may be appropriate and what the next steps forward are prior to engaging their services.
“We welcome every conversation, really. Yes, we’re a commercial business but we’re there to genuinely try and help people and we completely understand how much stress they are under. This problem is across every industry, every demographic, every size of business and every state and territory. I’m having many dark conversations each week with potential clients, and we certainly don’t want to add to that stress. If we genuinely don’t think we can help, we aren’t there to muck people around. Often a good chat on our initial call can give some guidance and set people at ease a little. If they never convert to a client, that’s ok, so long as they walk away with a better understanding of their options and further clarity on their situation,” he says.
Tax Debt Manager can generally complete an initial assessment within two or three business days once the necessary information has been supplied.
For accountants, Zell suggests the decision to seek help should be guided by the complexity of the matter, the urgency of the client’s circumstances and the accountant’s own capacity to manage negotiations and the time it takes to get a satisfactory result.
“We’d say the right time for an accountant to get in touch is when ATO debt appears to raise its head and there is a general sense that it could become an issue. The accountant is usually under pressure from a time and capacity perspective so we’re there to hopefully help clients navigate their obligations, if the accountant or client doesn’t need us then we’re happy,”he says.
He also emphasises that bringing in a specialist does not mean relinquishing the client relationship. Instead, TDM aims to complement the accountant’s existing role, providing focused expertise in ATO debt matters while the practitioner continues to advise on the client’s broader financial circumstances.
“We’re there to be a value add to any accountancy business that needs us, ideally we would never be needed but with ATO debt as large as it is, and business owners under more pressure than ever, we simply want to be viewed as a valuable resource to help if and when needed,” Zell says.
Understanding the options before it’s too late
For accountants, the challenge is to recognise when a client’s circumstances require more specialised attention and ensure those discussions take place before the situation deteriorates.
This will be a central theme of Zell’s upcoming IPA webinar, Supporting Clients Through Tax Debt Challenges, on Tuesday 24 November.
Drawing on his work atTDM, he will examine changes in the ATO’s approach to debt collection, the challenges involved in negotiating payment arrangements and GIC remission applications, how this has changed from what many in the accounting industry may have been used to over the past few years and the practical strategies that can help businesses regain financial stability.
He will also discuss real client experiences and explain when specialist tax debt support may be appropriate.
Zell hopes the session will give accountants a clearer understanding of the current environment and the options available to their clients.
“We know from speaking to many accountants on a regular basis that the way they are approaching ATO debt is what would have worked two years ago but doesn’t necessarily now. In actual fact, they may be inadvertently harming their client’s chances of a favourable outcome. There are many subtle changes that need to be considered,” he says.
“The purpose of the webinar is around creating awareness for accountants of an extra solution to consider calling upon to tackle ATO debt prior to any death knell, we simply want advisers and clients to explore what may be possible before taking drastic action which could affect clients severely for years to come. Nothing lost, nothing gained.
“The overall aim is to help individuals and business owners of Australia survive through their tough times and come out the other side doing what they set out to do. Putting dollars and commercials aside, there is massive benefit and societal impact to achieving this goal. Marriages stay together, kids stay with the family unit, self-harm doesn’t occur, the strain on the hospital and welfare system comes down and domestic violence is avoided. These are all regularly mentioned on calls I have and it’s hugely uplifting when we can help an accountant and their client get a great outcome.”
For businesses under pressure, the awareness of an alternate solution may make a considerable difference. An unaffordable payment arrangement or a decision to enter formal insolvency can have consequences that extend well beyond the immediate tax liability.
For accountants, knowing when to seek specialist support and having someone to turn to that eases their day to day pressure may be just as important as knowing how to negotiate with the ATO. And for clients facing mounting tax debt, that decision could help determine whether a temporary financial setback becomes a lasting business crisis.
Supporting Clients Through Tax Debt Challenges
Tax debt can be overwhelming for business owners and individuals alike and knowing how best to support clients through these situations is becoming increasingly important. In this webinar, the team from Tax Debt Manager will share insights from the frontline of ATO debt negotiations, including current challenges, real client success stories, and practical strategies that have helped businesses get back on track.
